Prudential Douglas Elliman awarded her the Top Retail and Commercial GCI for 2005 and 2006.
In 1992, Crain's New York Business called her a Rising Star and in 1996, one of New York's 75 Most Influential Women in Business. Three years later, Crain’s named her one of New York's 100 Most Influential Women in Business, a distinction she earned again in 2007.
In 1999, she was Woman of the Year by the Associated Builders and Owners of Greater New York, a first-ever for the trade association.
In 2000, she received the AREW Founder's Award, the honor which she originated. Ms. Consolo received another AREW award, that of Outstanding Woman of Achievement, and is a Woman of Valor by the Capuchin Order of St. John the Baptist Friary.
The non-profit organization Dress for Success honored Ms. Consolo with a Success at Its Best Award in 2005.
